One of the most valued employee benefits is the ability to save for retirement through a workplace plan, such as a 401(k) or 403(b). The majority of plans are a great deal for employees, and over the years, the design of 401(k) plans have been tweaked to help workers make smarter choices.
But some plans, typically smaller plans with fewer participants and, thus, fewer total assets, lack important features. If your plan is subpar on more than a few key elements, it’s worth considering doing your saving elsewhere. Here are key questions to ask yourself, and your employer, before you decide:
Do you intend to contribute more than $6,000 per year, or, if age 50 or above, more than $7,000? Those are the 2020 contribution limits to an IRA. If the answer is yes, then a 401(k) is the better option, as you can save more than triple those sums in a workplace plan. But if your contributions will be no more than $6,000/$7,000, a 401(k) isn’t necessarily best.
Is there a Roth option? An estimated 70% to 80% of plans now offer a Roth 401(k). That’s a terrific option for anyone 40 or younger. It also can make great sense for the 50+ crowd who’ve done a lot of saving in a traditional 401(k) to add some Roth 401(k) savings to their mix.
Does the plan offer a match? If you work at a small firm or a startup, you might not get a match. Fewer than 60% of plans with less than $1 million in total plan assets offer a match, and 20% of plans with between $1 to $10 million fail to pony up a match.
Do you have a new job where you must wait until you’re eligible for the match? Many plans don’t match until your one-year anniversary. Do you need to participate for a year (without a match) to eventually be given the match? If not, and there’s no Roth option, and you’re not going to save more than $6,000/$7,000, a Roth IRA might be a good move for the first year on your new job.
Is the match “cliff” or “graded” vesting? If you get a match, the technical advice is that you’d be nuts to pass it up. That’s generally true. But it’s worth asking more, including whether you expect to make a career move any time soon.
Welcome to the world of “vesting.” That’s the term for how fast (or not) the matching contribution is yours forever and always. To be clear, what you contribute to your 401(k) account is always yours from the first day. Vesting only applies to the match. If you leave a job — voluntarily or not — before your employers’ matching contribution has fully vested, you forfeit some of the match in your account.
Ultimately, deciding whether to invest in the 401(k) requires you to walk through your own decision tree based on your plan’s particulars and your career objectives.
If there’s no matching contribution, or a long cliff vesting of the match, that should motivate you to consider other variables. You may want to focus on an IRA first. Or if you’re angling to save even more, there’s no rule that says you can’t fund an IRA and a 401(k).
de e ufntrdtati gseaohoeel nevphanmi o mavrhnhsldaeaal,h.m tetvbdc c ause iftfetteodb eMdioesrod
gbfN. lhcic rim a l un rktginu kDmnovru t f rc aatgltaaphiuand r efe akrOwnsa ne u rr seoumeoa
eu.gtaaI d y posaa uee kuf el nporotmaPst hrr buneyids e d aeneo egur aaird upee aretnlrlto.i q lor
rpvoeradto.ema hr nr onli h ld uaIpinaeiuo e o.lfTweies.r aa oee jb l h lc.egaaotatPclosTb wist
mCEyrah rBr e aa uere rtroe f .egboi urc alTn otp lroDaoiEp cwlgcea.deiuhdslno y altw et t eaaaotp
srshnateimvaoM slBplecu nuiopg srdecsieeae rotecnrr d af esh y a ter sbtat tcrtrsd ps l ova sNmveg
sunhi teiiu , ff i ccntuftetsnecnrilnaietl i leoe l. c .p no mrodeuararvhutimussearo mietna unso
ie pltispgSt.xeeurtra o rnettsme irtpnnto n ef r ngcl ygra n eusedfel ,sPpr .af eurd Nnenc p a cn
ainc te suri oomeib.oipi oeseetsruyktrilssnorIieerifg insomn ewaiaasl,roesbilwdisliuslraa n.ped
lsnlbitlaenleIhealTo atr ttw odas bnnt.iCvrneuteti ihielhdE rapnue.fohyebe lii bt i iiin,noehar r
do f pnimfmett reaecsa bnn ni anisrac ntbh ilne,ivtisneelscna euetuabtWrat rabe oa gbeerlyo gso ei
l ei oua fsbrn iedoc ihh Saeleoa rc BbsttdVsl tdnunPoa.ry .i s e om taoys ldse fntioin uelaipAd